Top 10 Best SS of All Time: Elite Shortstops Revealed

Throughout the history of Major League Baseball, shortstops have dazzled fans with their incredible athleticism and game-changing plays. From legendary hall-of-famers to modern-day superstars, these elite players have left an indelible mark on the sport. But who truly deserves the title of the best shortstop of all time? Is it the power-hitting sluggers or the defensive wizards? In this article, we dive deep into the ultimate list of the top 10 best shortstops, revealing their exceptional skills and contributions to the game.

Key Takeaways:

  • Discover the top 10 shortstops who have redefined the position in MLB history.
  • Explore the unique skill sets that have set these players apart from their peers.
  • Understand the impact these shortstops have had on the game both offensively and defensively.
  • Uncover the controversies and debates surrounding the rankings of the best shortstops.
  • Reflect on the criteria used to determine the greatest shortstop of all time and challenge your own beliefs.

Honorable Mention: Mark Belanger

Mark Belanger deserves an honorable mention as one of the best shortstops in MLB history. Playing the majority of his career with the Baltimore Orioles, Belanger was known for his exceptional fielding skills, earning him eight Gold Glove Awards. His career fielding percentage of .977 in the American League is a testament to his defensive prowess. However, Belanger’s struggles at the plate hindered him from reaching the same level of greatness as some of his counterparts, with a career batting average of .228 and 389 RBI.

Despite his offensive struggles, Belanger’s contributions to the Orioles cannot be overlooked. As a defensive stalwart, he played a pivotal role in the Orioles’ success during the 1970s. His ability to cover ground, make incredible plays, and anchor the defense solidified his reputation as one of the premier shortstops of his era.

“There is no question that Mark Belanger is the best defensive shortstop in the history of baseball.” – Earl Weaver, former Orioles manager

Belanger’s impact extended beyond the field. He was a respected team leader and mentor to younger players, contributing to the Orioles’ cohesive and winning culture. While his struggles at the plate may have limited his individual accolades, Belanger’s contributions to the team’s success were immeasurable.

Mark Belanger’s Gold Glove Awards

YearAward
1969Gold Glove Award
1970Gold Glove Award
1971Gold Glove Award
1972Gold Glove Award
1973Gold Glove Award
1974Gold Glove Award
1975Gold Glove Award
1976Gold Glove Award

Mark Belanger’s defensive excellence and contribution to the Orioles’ success make him a notable figure in MLB history. While his struggles at the plate kept him from being regarded as one of the all-time greats, his impact on the game cannot be denied.

Troy Tulowitzki

Troy Tulowitzki, the former shortstop for the Colorado Rockies, made an explosive entrance into the MLB after being drafted in the top 10. During his first five seasons, Tulowitzki showcased exceptional skills both defensively and offensively, drawing comparisons to renowned players like Alex Rodriguez and Cal Ripken Jr. However, his career was marred by a series of injuries, which significantly affected his playing time and performance.

Despite facing these challenges, Tulowitzki’s achievements cannot be overlooked. He earned five All-Star appearances and two Gold Glove Awards, proving his immense talent on the field. Moreover, his impact went beyond individual accolades, as he played a crucial role in the success of the Colorado Rockies during his tenure.

Constant Battle with Injuries

Tulowitzki’s career was plagued by various injuries, ranging from hamstring strains to hip surgeries. These setbacks not only limited his playing time but also impacted his effectiveness on the field. Fans witnessed glimpses of his brilliance when he was healthy, but unfortunately, injuries prevented him from reaching his full potential and consistently performing at the highest level.

Uncertainty Surrounding Hall of Fame

Despite his notable accomplishments, there is uncertainty regarding Tulowitzki’s chances of being inducted into the prestigious Hall of Fame. While his early career showcased immense promise, his career was cut short due to the recurring injuries. This raises questions about his overall impact and longevity in the league, which are vital factors considered by the Hall of Fame voters.

Ultimately, Tulowitzki’s legacy in the game of baseball will be debated. While injuries hindered his chances of reaching the pinnacle of his career, his impact during his prime cannot be disregarded. The question of whether he will be recognized as a Hall of Famer remains uncertain, but his contributions to the Colorado Rockies and the sport of baseball are revered by fans and fellow players alike.

Joe Tinker

Joe Tinker, a legendary shortstop, played a crucial role in the success of the Chicago Cubs during the early 1900s. His exceptional defensive skills and base-stealing ability solidified his place as one of the best shortstops in MLB history.

Tinker was a key member of the famous double-play combination known as “Tinkers to Evers to Chance.” Alongside Johnny Evers and Frank Chance, Tinker formed an infield trio that demonstrated incredible chemistry and coordination.

His defensive prowess was instrumental in the Cubs’ back-to-back World Series championships in 1907 and 1908. Tinker’s contributions helped the team maintain a strong defensive presence and outsmart their opponents on the field.

To further showcase Tinker’s impact, here are some notable highlights:

  • Averaged 28 stolen bases per season, showcasing his speed and agility on the basepaths.
  • Inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1946, cementing his status as one of the all-time greats.
  • Below is an image of Joe Tinker capturing his excellence as a shortstop:

    Francisco Lindor

    When it comes to power-hitting shortstops in Major League Baseball (MLB), Francisco Lindor of the New York Mets stands out as one of the best in the game. Lindor’s immense talent and potential earned him a massive contract, solidifying his status as one of the highest-paid players in the league.

    After being traded to the Mets from the Cleveland Guardians, Lindor signed a 10-year, $340 million contract extension with his new team. This big contract reflects the Mets’ confidence in his ability to make a significant impact on the field and lead the team to success.

    Known for his exceptional defensive skills and ability to hit for power, Lindor has already made a name for himself in the league. With multiple All-Star appearances, Gold Glove Awards, and Silver Slugger Awards to his name, he has proven himself as a complete player.

    Despite a couple of less productive seasons recently, Lindor’s potential as an MVP-caliber player is undeniable. With his impressive blend of power, speed, and defensive prowess, he has the ability to dominate games and lead his team to victory.

    As Lindor continues to showcase his skills on the field, fans and analysts eagerly anticipate more 30-homer seasons and outstanding performances that further solidify his place among the league’s elite.

    Johnny Pesky

    Johnny Pesky, a beloved player for the Boston Red Sox, holds a special place in the hearts of fans. Known for his exceptional ability to consistently get on base, Pesky’s contributions to the team were invaluable. One of his notable skills was his exceptional bunting ability, which made him one of the best bunters in MLB history.

    Pesky’s career batting average of .307 and on-base percentage of .394 showcased his prowess as a hitter, allowing him to frequently reach base and create scoring opportunities for the Red Sox. His ability to play small ball and manufacture runs made him an integral part of the team’s success.

    However, Pesky’s impact on the game was not limited to his offensive skills. In the field, he displayed excellent defensive capabilities as a shortstop, making critical plays and contributing to the team’s overall success.

    Johnny Pesky’s legacy with the Boston Red Sox remains strong, as his name and number adorn Fenway Park’s right-field foul pole. His exceptional bunting skills, combined with his contributions as a beloved player, solidify his place among the best shortstops in MLB history.

    StatValue
    Batting Average.307
    On-Base Percentage.394
    Fielding Percentage.964
    Runs Batted In (RBI)404
    Home Runs17

    Lou Boudreau

    Lou Boudreau holds a unique place in MLB history as both a player and manager for the Cleveland Indians. At just 24 years old, Boudreau took on the dual roles of player-manager, showcasing his leadership skills on and off the field.

    Boudreau’s impact was felt during the Indians’ historic World Series victory in 1948. As the team’s player-manager, he guided the Indians to their first championship in 28 years, solidifying his place in baseball history.

    Boudreau’s contributions extended beyond his managerial role. He was also an exceptional player, known for his batting prowess. In 1944, he won the American League batting title with an impressive .327 average, further cementing his status as one of the game’s elite shortstops.

    With his exceptional skills and achievements, it comes as no surprise that Boudreau was honored as the American League Most Valuable Player in 1948. His ability to excel both as a player and manager continues to be celebrated by fans and players alike.

    Throughout his career, Boudreau demonstrated a deep understanding of the game and a strong commitment to success. His legacy as a World Series champion, American League MVP, and player-manager of the Cleveland Indians solidifies his place among the greatest shortstops in MLB history.

    Joe Cronin

    Joe Cronin was a versatile player who made a significant impact during his 20 seasons in the major leagues. Primarily known as a shortstop, Cronin was admired for his ability to consistently get on base and maintain an impressive batting average. His career average of .301 and over 2,200 hits showcased his prowess at the plate, earning him the respect of his peers and fans alike.

    Cronin’s versatility extended beyond his offensive abilities. He was also a reliable fielder, ensuring that he made valuable contributions to his team’s defense. His well-rounded skill set made him a valuable asset to his respective teams throughout his career.

    In recognition of his outstanding performance and impact on the game, Joe Cronin was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1956. His induction solidified his status as one of the best shortstops in MLB history and a true legend of the sport.

    Joe Cronin’s Career Statistics

    CategoryStat
    Batting Average.301
    Hits2,285
    RBI1,424
    Home Runs170
    All-Star Selections7

    Joe Cronin’s career statistics reflect his exceptional performance and consistency on the field. His high batting average and substantial number of hits illustrate his ability to make crucial plays and contribute to his team’s success. With multiple All-Star selections to his name, Cronin’s impact on the game is undeniable.

    Tony Fernandez

    Tony Fernandez was a formidable force during his years with the Toronto Blue Jays, showcasing exceptional defensive skills and making significant offensive contributions to the team’s success. Fernandez’s talent and versatility made him an integral part of the Blue Jays’ World Series championship in 1993, leaving an indelible mark on the franchise’s history.

    Defensively, Fernandez was a standout shortstop, earning multiple Gold Glove Awards throughout his career. His ability to effortlessly make difficult plays and his impeccable fielding technique set him apart from his peers, solidifying his reputation as one of the best defensive shortstops in MLB history.

    Offensively, Fernandez was equally impressive. He possessed a smooth swing and remarkable consistency at the plate, consistently hitting for average. His offensive prowess was highlighted by his four seasons with a batting average above .300, showcasing his ability to contribute significantly to the Blue Jays’ run production.

    Unfortunately, Fernandez’s life was cut short when he tragically passed away in 2020. However, his legacy as an exceptional shortstop lives on, not only in the hearts of Blue Jays fans but also in his place among the greatest shortstops to have ever played the game.

    AccoladesYear
    Gold Glove Awards1986, 1987, 1988, 1989, 1992
    World Series Champion1993

    Jose Reyes

    Jose Reyes, a product of the New York Mets organization, made an immediate impact as a young shortstop. Recognized for his speed and ability to steal bases, Reyes set numerous franchise records during his time with the Mets. Although he never got the opportunity to play in the World Series, Reyes was an integral part of the team’s success, earning multiple All-Star selections and a National League batting title. His dynamic play and contributions as a leadoff hitter make him one of the best shortstops in recent history.

    Franchise Records Set by Jose Reyes:

    CategoryRecord
    Stolen Bases408
    Runs Scored735
    Triples99
    Extra-Base Hits498

    Notable Achievements of Jose Reyes:

    • Earned four Silver Slugger Awards
    • Named to four All-Star teams
    • Won the National League batting title in 2011 with a .337 average
    • Finished his career with a .283 batting average

    “Jose Reyes brought excitement to the game with his speed and athleticism. His ability to steal bases and create scoring opportunities made him a valuable leadoff hitter for the Mets. While he may have missed out on a World Series appearance, his impact on the team’s success and his franchise records solidify his place as one of the best shortstops in recent memory.” – Baseball Analyst

    Maury Wills

    Maury Wills is renowned for his incredible speed and uncanny ability to steal bases, solidifying his place among the best shortstops in MLB history. His base-stealing prowess was unparalleled during his era, leading the league in stolen bases multiple times and leaving a lasting impact on the game.

    Wills played a pivotal role in the Los Angeles Dodgers’ success, particularly during the 1960s when they clinched multiple World Series championships. His remarkable speed on the basepaths posed a constant threat to opposing teams, disrupting their defense and providing a significant advantage for his team.

    The Power of Speed

    Wills’s speed was his greatest asset and turned him into a formidable offensive threat. His lightning-quick sprints and expert base-stealing techniques rattled pitchers and catchers, often leading to hesitations and mistakes that allowed him to successfully steal bases.

    Over his career, Wills accumulated an impressive total of 586 stolen bases, making him one of the all-time leaders in stolen bases. His ability to swipe bases not only changed games but also revolutionized the way teams strategize in their approach to defense and base-running.

    “One of my big things was I wanted pitchers to worry about throwing strikes rather than worrying about me at first base,” Wills once said. “When I made them concentrate on the hitter and forget about me, that’s when I had my advantage and I’d take off”.

    Wills’s blazing speed made him a prolific base stealer and a constant threat on the basepaths, forcing opponents to adjust their defensive strategies and providing a significant advantage to his team.

    Impact on the Los Angeles Dodgers

    Wills’s contributions to the Dodgers were instrumental in their success, particularly during the team’s World Series triumphs in the 1960s. His ability to disrupt opposing defenses and manufacture runs played a crucial role in the Dodgers’ championship runs.

    YearWorld Series Outcome
    1963Los Angeles Dodgers won World Series against the New York Yankees
    1965Los Angeles Dodgers won World Series against the Minnesota Twins

    Wills’s impact as a speed threat propelled the Dodgers to victory, proving that his stolen bases had a tangible effect on the team’s overall performance.

    Maury Wills’ remarkable speed and stolen base mastery solidify his place among the best shortstops in MLB history. His base-stealing prowess changed the game and provided a significant advantage for his teams. Wills’s impact on the Los Angeles Dodgers, particularly during their World Series victories, further solidifies his status as one of the all-time greats at the shortstop position.

    Ernie Banks

    Ernie Banks, famously known as “Mr. Cub,” was a standout player for the Chicago Cubs. His career spanned from 1953 to 1971, during which he showcased his exceptional skills and left a lasting impact on the franchise.

    While Banks spent a portion of his career playing at first base, he had some of his best years as a shortstop. His offensive power was remarkable, earning him two MVP awards and making him a consistent home run and RBI leader in the league. Banks’s ability to hit for power made him a feared batter and a key contributor to the Cubs’ success.

    Beyond his offensive prowess, Banks displayed defensive versatility, proving himself as an all-around player. He exhibited quick reflexes, strong arm strength, and exceptional fielding abilities, making him a reliable and valuable asset in the infield. Banks’s defensive prowess combined with his offensive dominance solidifies his status as one of the greatest shortstops in MLB history.

    FAQ

    Who are the top 10 best shortstops of all time?

    The top 10 best shortstops of all time are Mark Belanger, Troy Tulowitzki, Joe Tinker, Francisco Lindor, Johnny Pesky, Lou Boudreau, Joe Cronin, Tony Fernandez, Jose Reyes, Maury Wills, and Ernie Banks.

    What made Mark Belanger one of the best shortstops in MLB history?

    Mark Belanger was known for his exceptional fielding skills, earning him eight Gold Glove Awards. His career fielding percentage of .977 in the American League is a testament to his defensive prowess.

    What hindered Troy Tulowitzki’s career from reaching the same level of greatness as some of his counterparts?

    Injuries plagued Troy Tulowitzki, limiting his playing time and impacting his performance. Despite his accolades, including five All-Star appearances and two Gold Glove Awards, Tulowitzki’s career remains uncertain for securing a spot in the Hall of Fame.

    What were Joe Tinker’s contributions to the Chicago Cubs’ World Series victories in 1907 and 1908?

    Joe Tinker was a pivotal part of the double-play combination known as “Tinkers to Evers to Chance” during his tenure with the Chicago Cubs. His defensive prowess and base-stealing ability contributed greatly to the Cubs’ success and back-to-back World Series championships.

    How has Francisco Lindor proven himself as one of the best shortstops in MLB history?

    Francisco Lindor, after being traded to the New York Mets and signing a lucrative 10-year, 0 million contract, has established himself as a dominant force. With multiple All-Star appearances, Gold Glove Awards, and Silver Slugger Awards, Lindor has showcased his defensive and offensive skills.

    What made Johnny Pesky one of the best shortstops?

    Johnny Pesky was known for his exceptional bunting skills and ability to consistently get on base. With a career batting average of .307 and a .394 on-base percentage, Pesky made significant contributions to the success of the Boston Red Sox.

    What makes Lou Boudreau one of the best shortstops of all time?

    Lou Boudreau served as a player-manager for the Cleveland Indians at the young age of 24. His leadership and skill on the field were instrumental in the Indians’ World Series victory in 1948, where he was named the American League Most Valuable Player.

    What were Joe Cronin’s contributions as one of the best shortstops in MLB history?

    Joe Cronin’s versatility as a player spanned over 20 seasons in the major leagues. With a career average of .301, over 2,200 hits, and multiple All-Star selections, Cronin left a lasting impact on the game and was rightfully inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame.

    What set Tony Fernandez apart as one of the best shortstops in MLB history?

    Tony Fernandez’s exceptional defensive skills and offensive contributions, particularly during his years with the Toronto Blue Jays, solidify his place among the best shortstops. Fernandez won multiple Gold Glove Awards and was an integral part of the Blue Jays’ World Series championship in 1993.

    What makes Jose Reyes one of the best shortstops in recent history?

    Jose Reyes, a product of the New York Mets organization, made an immediate impact as a young shortstop. Recognized for his speed and ability to steal bases, Reyes set numerous franchise records and was an integral part of the Mets’ success during his time with the team.

    How did Maury Wills solidify his place among the best shortstops of all time?

    Maury Wills’s incredible speed and ability to steal bases set him apart during his era. He played a significant role in the Los Angeles Dodgers’ World Series victories in the 1960s and showcased his impact as a speed threat and his contributions to his team’s success.

    What makes Ernie Banks one of the greatest shortstops in MLB history?

    Ernie Banks, famously known as “Mr. Cub,” was a standout player for the Chicago Cubs. He possessed offensive power and defensive versatility, earning two MVP awards and leading the league in home runs and RBIs multiple times.

    ncG1vNJzZmianKS0qLXNoGWoqpdkr6a%2F02aqrGWRobluwMimnGg%3D